
Cardinal Robert McElroy, a close ally of Pope Leo XIV and a leading figure in the Catholic Church, has delivered a sharp rebuke of the Trump administration’s immigration policies. In an interview with CNN, McElroy denounced the mass deportation of immigrants as “morally repugnant” and in direct conflict with the values of the Catholic faith, voicing broader concerns about the administration’s domestic and foreign policy decisions.
I. Cardinal Condemns Immigration Crackdown
1. Mass Deportations Deemed Inhumane
Speaking from Rome, Cardinal McElroy criticized the aggressive enforcement of immigration laws under Trump, stating that what began as border control has turned into widespread, indiscriminate deportations that tear families apart. “This goes far beyond national security—it’s about inflicting fear on millions,” he said.

2. Fear and Disruption in Religious Spaces
He expressed concern that even places of worship are no longer seen as safe by immigrants, citing the administration’s removal of protections for sensitive locations such as churches. McElroy believes this climate of fear is rooted in xenophobia, echoing America’s long history of viewing new immigrants as inferior.
II. Church and Government Clash Over Moral Responsibility
1. Targeting the Vulnerable
McElroy referenced immigration raids in everyday places—like car washes and retail parking lots—as evidence that authorities are not focusing solely on individuals with criminal records. He emphasized that many of the deported had long-standing ties to the U.S. and had contributed meaningfully to society.
2. Funding Allegations Refuted
Responding to criticism from Vice President JD Vance—who claimed the church’s opposition was financially motivated due to federal funding—McElroy argued that church resources consistently exceed what the government provides. “Anyone making those accusations hasn’t done the math,” he said.
3. A Broader Vision of Immigration
While Pope Leo XIV has framed immigration as a global concern, McElroy believes his message carries significant weight for Americans. The Pope, himself a descendant of immigrants, has urged compassion and respect for migrants—principles McElroy says are not being upheld by current U.S. policy.
III. Criticism of Economic and Military Policies
1. Opposition to “Big, Beautiful Bill”
McElroy also challenged Trump’s sweeping tax and spending proposal, warning that it would slash social programs and remove healthcare access from millions while enriching the wealthy. He signed a joint letter with other faith leaders to formally oppose the legislation.
2. Concerns Over Military Escalation
Turning to foreign policy, McElroy criticized recent U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iranian nuclear sites, expressing fear that such actions might push other nations to develop nuclear weapons as a defensive measure. “This could lead to increased proliferation, which is deeply troubling,” he warned.
IV. Advocating for Church Reform
1. Elevating Women in Church Leadership
Addressing internal Church matters, McElroy emphasized the importance of examining the absence of women in decision-making roles. He supports ordaining women as deacons—a position within Catholic theology that allows for ministerial duties without performing Mass or hearing confessions.
2. A Shift in Church Priorities
He noted that recent Vatican discussions have increasingly focused on gender inclusion, signaling a shift in the Church’s priorities. “We must ask why women are missing from so many roles and begin correcting that imbalance,” McElroy stated.
V. A Theological and Political Perspective
1. Academic Background Shapes Views
Cardinal McElroy, who holds a doctorate in political science from Stanford, brings a scholarly lens to his public positions. His academic work on moral norms in foreign policy has influenced his stance on nuclear weapons and the ethical responsibility of global leaders.
2. Anticipating a Papal Visit
McElroy also shared optimism that Pope Leo XIV, a Chicago native, will eventually visit the U.S., calling it a potentially historic and unifying moment for the country and the Church.
Conclusion
Cardinal Robert McElroy has emerged as a vocal critic of the Trump administration, taking a firm stance on immigration, social justice, economic inequality, and foreign policy. Rooted in Catholic doctrine and moral theology, his views underscore the growing tension between religious leadership and political power. As debates over national identity and human dignity continue, voices like McElroy’s provide a sharp moral lens on policies affecting millions.













